There’s nothing quite like Indian sweets to bring a smile to your face and a little comfort to your day. Whether it’s a box of gulab jamun for a cozy weekend, or a tray of motichoor ladoos lighting up your festive table, these treats are more than just food, they’re little pieces of home.
Living in Chicago means you’re lucky enough to be surrounded by amazing food, but when it comes to authentic Indian sweets, the search can still be hit or miss. The good news? You no longer need to hunt down that one store in Devon Avenue or wait for someone to fly in from India. These days, some of the best mithai shops are just a click away.
So if you’re wondering where to buy authentic Indian sweets online in Chicago, here’s a round-up of trusted names that deliver quality, nostalgia, and the sweetness you’re craving, right to your door.
- Rajbhog Foods
Rajbhog is one of those names you’ll hear in almost every Indian household in the U.S., and for good reason. With over 40 years in the business, they’ve mastered the art of classic mithai. Their sweets are made in the U.S. (mostly in New Jersey) using traditional methods, and shipped with vacuum-sealed packaging so everything arrives fresh.
Why we love it:
- Their gulab jamun is warm, soft, and syrupy – just how mom used to make
- They offer a wide variety, from rasgulla and peda to festive gift packs
- Great option for bulk orders or celebrations
If you’re shopping for Rakhi, Diwali or even just a rainy day craving, Rajbhog is always a safe (and delicious) bet.
- Shaheen Sweets
Shaheen Sweets is based in New Jersey and loved across the country, Shaheen Sweets is one of those rare gems that still handmakes every batch of mithai. You’ll taste the difference, especially in their motichoor ladoos, which are soft, fresh, and not overly sweet.
What makes them special:
- Old-school flavors and no shortcuts in prep
- Cham cham, kalakand, and rasmalai that feel straight out of a family kitchen
- Beautiful packaging for gifting
They’ve been around since 1973, and you can tell, they know what they’re doing. It’s perfect when you want mithai that actually feels real, not factory-made.
- Almond House
If you’re someone who enjoys the fancier side of Indian sweets (think dry fruits, elegant boxes, and sweets that don’t feel overly sugary), Almond House is a name you need to know. Originally from Hyderabad, they now ship internationally, including to Chicago.
Why it’s worth a try:
- Their kaju katli is next level – smooth, rich, and perfectly balanced
- Badam burfi, dry fruit laddoos, and festive gift boxes that look and taste beautiful
- Great for weddings, corporate gifting, or classy celebrations
It’s the kind of mithai you send when you really want to impress, whether it’s a client, a family member, or honestly, just yourself.
- Mithaas
Mithaas brings a fresh feel to desi sweets. Their flavors stay true to tradition, but the presentation is sleek and delivery-friendly. If you’re new to Indian sweets or want to send something to a friend who’s not super familiar with mithai, Mithaas is a great middle ground.
What they’re known for:
- Soan papdi that’s light and flaky, not overly sweet
- Gajar halwa that comes frozen and reheats beautifully
- A wide variety of sweets and even fusion treats
It’s also a good pick for last-minute gifting or sweet cravings that hit midweek.
- Sukhadia’s
Sukhadia’s is a household name for anyone who grew up on Gujarati sweets and farsan. Originally from Gujarat and now based in the U.S., they offer everything from mohanthal and magaj to chikki, and they do it with consistency and care.
Why people love them:
- Authentic regional flavors, especially for those from Gujarat or Rajasthan
- Good mix of sweets and snacks , perfect for family gatherings
- Vacuum-packed and easy to ship across Chicago
If you’re craving flavors from back home or introducing someone to sweets beyond the basics, Sukhadia’s is where to look.
- The Baklava Box
Okay, this isn’t strictly an Indian sweet shop, but hear us out. The Baklava Box delivers beautifully layered, syrup-soaked baklava that hits the same spot as jalebi or balushahi. If you love flaky, nutty, sticky sweets, this is a lovely addition to your mithai table.
Why it’s a fun choice:
- Variety packs with pistachio, walnut, or chocolate
- Perfect for when you want something different but familiar
- Great for fusion parties or when your sweet tooth wants a twist
They also make stunning gift boxes, ideal for birthdays or “just because” treats.
- SweeDesi
SweeDesi is part of the new generation of Indian food startups in the U.S. fresh designs, curated gift boxes, and sweets that look as good as they taste. If you like bite-sized desserts, fusion mithai, or thoughtful presentations, this one’s for you.
Why it’s worth exploring:
- Cute mini mithai gift sets and sampler packs
- Modern packaging, perfect for gifting or corporate use
- Options for pan-Indian sweets and flavors
They’re especially popular around the holidays, but worth bookmarking year-round.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re missing home, planning a pooja, or just really craving that perfect bite of gulab jamun, you don’t have to settle for whatever’s closest. Chicago may be far from India, but with Rajbhog, Shaheen, Almond House, Mithaas, Sukhadia, The Baklava Box, and SweeDesi all delivering online, you’ve got plenty of options for authentic, affordable, and full of flavor.
So treat yourself. Order that mithai box. Share it or don’t, we won’t judge.
